It seemed liked it was never going to happen.
To make a long aggravating story short, I ordered from Macy's online and ended up having my order canceled and was unable to get the items again.
I ordered from MAC but could only get the yellow items pictured below. These are the Ever So Yellow pigment, Bright Side Lip Glass, and Playland Lipstick.
Here are the swatches. From left to right - Ever So Yellow, Bright Side, and Playland.
Then when all hope was lost that I would be able to get the others items I wanted, which were the Sweet Experience and Toying Around Lipsticks, I was informed of a store called Belk. I was told that they had all of the lipsticks in stock. Belk isn't a local store to me and I had never heard of it, but hopeful, I went on their website and sure enough they had them. There was no sales tax and free shipping so I pressed the order button.
They came in the mail yesterday and here they are pictured below.
Swatches of the Playland Lipsticks from left to right - Sweet Experience, Toying Around, and Playland.
I like them all, but I would have to say that Sweet Experience is my favorite. Which is yours?